2025 NFL Draft Betting Guide: Top-5 Picks

  • Cam Ward has -5000 odds to be selected first overall.
  • Travis Hunter, Shedeur Sanders, Abdul Carter, Will Campbell, and Mason Graham all have odds to be top-5 picks.

GREEN BAY, Wisc. – The 2025 NFL Draft is quickly approaching with under a month to go until the Tennessee Titans are on the clock.

With that, college football prop betting sites are continuing to pour in NFL Draft odds with odds now available for each of the top 5 picks.

The only pick that some are already saying is set in stone is the first pick, where Cam Ward has been linked to the Tennessee Titans for months leading up to the draft. Other than that, picks 2-5 seem to be as open as ever.

Pick 2: Cleveland Browns

2nd Overall Pick Odds

  • Travis Hunter (COL) -250
  • Abdul Carter (PSU) +185
  • Shedeur Sanders (COL) +1300
  • Cameron Ward +6000
  • Tyler Warren (PSU) +7500
  • Jaxson Dart (MISS) +8000

While the Cleveland Browns do have options here, it’s hard to see them taking Travis Hunter here when they need some serious help in other spots. One of their most needed positions is under center at QB, where Deshaun Watson just hasn’t panned out. With Ward likely off the board first, it leaves Shedeur Sanders as an option or even potentially Jaxson Dart, who has been climbing up draft boards as of late.

The Browns could also lean Abdul Carter out of Penn State and pair him next to Myles Garrett on the defensive line as a way to please him after he requested a trade.

Pick 3: New York Giants

3rd Overall Pick Odds

  • Abdul Carter (PSU) -180
  • Travis Hunter (COL) +250
  • Shedeur Sanders (COL) +400
  • Armand Membou (MIZZ) +7500
  • Jaxson Dart (MISS) +7500
  • Mason Graham (MICH) +7500

This is a great value on Sanders here going to the New York Giants. He’s made it extremely clear that the Giants is where he wants to be and it seems that they have mutual interest. Now, if Sanders does get picks to Cleveland, NYG could go best available and fill a need on the defensive line with Carter.

Pick 4: New England Patriots

4th Overall Pick Odds

  • Will Campbell (LSU) +125
  • Armand Membou (MIZZ) +330
  • Abdul Carter (PSU) +400
  • Jalon Walker (UGA) +1000
  • Travis Hunter (COL) +1000
  • Mason Graham (MICH) +1200

The New England Patriots selection could play out a few ways. The first is that Travis Hunter slips to them and they give both their secondary and receiver room a quality bump for Drake Maye. Now, if Hunter is selected in the top 3, they do have a massive need on the offensive line and both Will Campbell and Armand Membou will be available and either will likely be selected here.

Pick 5: Jacksonville Jaguars

5th Overall Pick Odds

  • Mason Graham (MICH) -145
  • Armand Membou (MIZZ) +500
  • Jalon Walker (UGA) +900
  • Will Campbell (LSU) +1100
  • Tyler Warren (PSU) +1300
  • Ashton Jeanty (BSU) +1600
  • Tetairoa McMillan (ARI) +1700

This pick to the Jacksonville Jaguars screams Mason Graham out of Michigan on the defensive line. They have a need on the defensive line as they were bottom five in sacks this season and in the bottom half of the league in TFL’s. This is a pure “need” rather than “wants” pick, and Graham is certainly a top-5 caliber player.

About Samuel Profeta

Sam is a college football enthusiast and who's been on the CollegeFootballProps.com team since 2020. He grew up a Florida State fan and graduated as a Nole in 2019. When he's not chopping it up about the Seminoles CFP snub, he's playing dynasty mode on College Football 25.